Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Modernism

While the Wikipedia article on Modernism is very useful (especially the historical summary), it is also long and detailed (Don't let me stop you from exploring it!). I wanted to find some succinct sources that epitomized Modernism for our course. Here are two. One is a very readable PowerPoint presentation I discovered by searching SlideShare (by Maria Teresa Ciaffaroni). The other is a handout from a 2008 course on Modernism taught by Sarah Brouillette I discovered by searching MIT's OpenCourseWare (after the break). Please browse through the SlideShare presentation, perhaps using some of the themes or people mentioned in the presentation as beginning points for your own self-directed learning.
How do these various aspects of modernism relate to our digital civilization today? Are we suffering a comparable sense of a loss of tradition? Does the technology that drives so much of our culture today confirm or challenge traditional systems? How does art play a role? Has it succumbed to mechanization and mass consumer culture (the concern of Walter Benjamin or Theodor Adorno)? Chime in. Don't forget to read past the break for that summary list from MIT.
Here are two lists I've taken from a handout by Sarah Brouillette provided for a Spring 2008 course on modernism at MIT (source):

Modernism
  1. Early 20th-century aesthetic movement (esp. 1910-30): TS Eliot, Virginia Woolf, James Joyce, Marcel Proust, Franz Kafka, etc.
  2. Rejected Victorian notions of art: its purposes, its formal features, and its relationship to its audience
  3. Emphasizes individual experience and perception (impressionism); concern with how the world is experienced (rather than what the world is). Think stream-of-consciousness writing.
  4. Movement away from fixed narrative points of view, like omniscient “all seeing, all knowing” narrators.
  5. Interest in blurring the boundaries between poetry and prose: less obviously distinct than they once were
  6. Interest in fragmentation and collage 
  7. An emphasis on self-reflexivity: the work of art draws attention to itself as a work of art 
  8. Blurring of the boundaries between popular art forms (photography, advertising, later film) and 'high art’ categories

Characteristics of Modernity
  1. I have a stable and coherent self who is rational and universal
  2. I know the world through reason and rationality
  3. I produce objective truth or "science” that isn’t constrained by me
  4. This truth is what leads to progress and improvement
  5. Reason, truth, and “the good” are synonymous
  6. Science is the best application of my rationality: it is neutral and objective and unbiased
  7. Language is how rationality is expressed and its discoveries communicated; it is “transparent” and can objectively represent the reality or the world (think photography)
  8. There is no difference between objects in the world and the words used to name them in language
  9. These premises stand behind and support EVERYTHING: democracy, law, ethics, and aesthetics



Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
What moves me most personally is bullet point 8 under the characteristics of modernity. Has anyone ever found themselves looking at a piece of art or a photograph, or read a poem and in the end there really is nothing necessary to say. There are feelings there, but they are already summed up in the piece of art itself and to try and say anything would be redundant. Maybe that is just me. I guess i am a modern man after all.
Honestly, Jake, I can usually think of something to say, but that's probably because of my current training in English major.

For your questions, Dr. Burton, I'd say that modernism is very closely parallel to the digital renaissance today. I'm blogging about this right now, so I'll expound there.
I agree with Kristen, I normally have a comment or two to make. But I think that is moving to post-modern ideals. Such as the idea that reactions should be portrayed and every idea is fragmented. I definitely think our views of poetry and prose are being blurred - digitally. It is becoming harder to find the difference between news and the Colbert Report, or the Daily Show, or Glen Beck. These political commentaries blur the lines of what is really happening and sensational representations of what people want to understand.
Two points stuck out to me. Modernism 3 hit home to me after reading TS Eliots "The Waste Land" and "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufock" Stream-of-consciousness writing is the only way i could describe them. It is as if TS Eliot had ADD because he jumps so quickly from topic to topic.

Characteristics of modernity 6. Freidrick Neitzsche said "God is Dead" I think the modern world still has a god they have just replaced the real one with 'science'.
It's interesting how each new "movement" in history challenges the things that were believed before that. Do you think we are, as humans, naturally cynical and want to challenge the world around us? Or is it just the fact that we haven't found out what true reality is?
Well, at the risk of sounding Newtonian, (which true Modernists may be none too impressed with) I would say that for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction in both physical and ideological movements. I think it is a natural thing for people to try to make sense of the world and discover their own personal reality.

Post a new comment

Comments by